DRAFT DAY DILEMMA: Did the Giants Make a Critical Mistake?
The 2025 NFL Draft has officially come and gone, leaving behind a trail of excitement, optimism, and in some cases, utter disappointment. For the New York Giants, their selection of Jaxson Dart with the 5th overall pick has sparked a heated debate among fans and pundits alike. As the team’s decision-makers look to rebuild their roster and reclaim their status as NFC East contenders, the question on everyone’s mind is: will they live to regret passing on Shedeur Sanders, the highly-touted quarterback prospect from Jackson State?
Travis Hunter: A Game-Changer
In-depth look at Hunter’s versatility and talent, and how he can make an immediate impact for the Jaguars
In 25 years of evaluating NFL prospects, I’ve never come across a player as versatile and talented as Hunter. He is truly one of one, earning my top grade as a receiver, as a cornerback and overall prospect. I absolutely believe that he can play both roles in the NFL, theoretically justifying the Jaguars’ aggressive trade up for him. Liam Coen was brought to Jacksonville to help Trevor Lawrence live up to his potential and get the Jaguars back into the playoffs. Adding Hunter to an offense that already boasts one of the NFL’s best young wideouts in Brian Thomas Jr. will do that. Adding a cornerback to challenge Thomas, as well, helps make this bold trade make sense. It had better, as trading their 2026 first-round selection to move up three spots is borderline reckless.
Grade: B
Carter’s Explosiveness
Analysis of the Giants’ selection of Carter and his potential to be an immediate Defensive Rookie of the Year candidate
Carter never ran for scouts prior to the draft, but he didn’t have to, as his explosiveness off the ball and in pursuit is just so obvious on tape. While certainly speedy off the ball, some have concerns about his ability to hold up in run support as Carter lacks ideal girth in his lower body — which is why he began his college career as an off-ball linebacker. In a league that prioritizes edge rushers more than any other defensive role, however, Carter’s value as an immediate 10-plus sack candidate justifies this selection. The perfect “finisher” to cap a dominant Giants defensive front, Carter is an obvious Defensive Rookie of the Year candidate.
Grade: A-
Campbell’s Fit with the Patriots
How Campbell’s skills align with the Patriots’ needs and their return to the “Patriot Way”
Campbell has everything NFL teams are looking for at the tackle position except ideal arm length. But, some have made far too much of his 33-inch arms, especially given how agile the 6-foot-6, 319-pounder moves. For a club desperate to protect the investment made a year ago in their rookie quarterback Drake Maye, this pick makes all of the sense in the world and is the perfect way for new head coach Mike Vrabel to put his stamp on the team. It isn’t flashy, but neither is Vrabel. This pick is about New England returning to the blue-collar physicality that epitomized the “Patriot Way.”
Grade: B+
Team-Specific Analysis
Giants’ Controversial Choice
Breaking down the Giants’ decision to take Jaxson Dart over Shedeur Sanders and what it means for their franchise
As safe as the cracker that shares his name, Graham is the blue-collar tough guy that fits what the Cleveland Browns are trying to build. He is a disruptive presence whose game should only take off with all of the attention opponents will be dedicating to Myles Garrett. Grah Michael Smith, acclaimed NFL reporter/analyst (NBC, Amazon, ESPN) and fantasy football legend (dude swears he actually invented Zero RB) brings you the definitive dynasty show … one dedicated to only the most devoted of diehards! Davis, Dylan, and Josh – commissioner and co-commishes for the gold standard of dynasty leagues, Jerry Jones’s Yacht Club – deliver you the insight, tips, and strategies you need to stay ahead of the game when it comes to building and sustaining that perennial championship contender(s). Don’t download unless you have designs on only one goal – domination! And don’t judge them on their winners; judge them on their losers because they have so few. Welcome to the next level, and you’re welcome in advance.
Listen, follow, rate & review The Dynasty Exchange here!
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/michael-smith-presents-the-dynasty-exchange/id1702690103
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
Conclusion
As we reflect on the 2025 NFL Draft, one pick that has sparked significant debate is the New York Giants’ decision to select Jaxson Dart over Shedeur Sanders. The article delves into the pros and cons of each choice, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of both players. While Dart’s impressive physical tools and potential for growth are undeniable, Sanders’ exceptional athleticism and NFL-ready skills make a strong case for why he should have been the top pick.
The significance of this debate extends beyond the individual players, as it speaks to the larger issue of draft strategy and team building. The Giants’ decision to prioritize Dart’s upside over Sanders’ immediate impact may have long-term consequences, potentially hindering their ability to compete in a crowded NFC East. As we look to the future, it will be crucial for teams to strike a balance between short-term needs and long-term potential, all while navigating the unpredictable nature of the draft.
In conclusion, the 2025 NFL Draft will be remembered for its thrilling moments and thought-provoking decisions. As we continue to monitor the development of Jaxson Dart and Shedeur Sanders, one thing is certain: the NFL Draft is a high-stakes game of chess, where every move has the potential to make or break a franchise. The Giants’ draft-day dilemma serves as a poignant reminder that, in the world of professional football, the line between triumph and tragedy is often razor-thin. Will the Giants’ gamble on Dart pay off, or will they come to regret passing on the NFL-ready talent of Sanders? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the 2025 NFL Draft will go down in history as a thrilling exercise in draft-day drama.