Here’s a captivating introduction for the article:
Amy Adams has been a Hollywood staple for over two decades, charming audiences with her radiant smile and effortless charm in films like “Junebug”, “Enchanted”, and “American Hustle”. But, as of late, her box office record has been a different story altogether. With a string of underwhelming performances and commercial disappointments, including “Justice League” and “The Woman in the Window”, it’s hard not to wonder: what’s going on?

What Will It Take To Get Amy Adams Out of Her Flop Era?

Everyone gets their flop era. Sometimes, life doesn’t go your way, and when it happens on a huge public platform, your professional struggles seem to take on the weight of cultural importance. For every And Justice For All, there’s a Saint Anger. Oscar winners get Razzie noms. World Cup victors stumble in the heats. Still, nobody likes it when their favourites seem forever stuck in a rut of creative failures, especially when they become somewhat incomprehensible or even irritating. We Amy Adams fans know the pain all too well, and it doesn’t feel like we’re out of the woods just yet.
Adams, a six-time Oscar nominee and industry-beloved actress, doesn’t need my defences. She’s a versatile performer who has done drama, comedy, musical, action, and sci-fi. She’s worked with Spielberg, Villeneuve, PTA, and Mike Nichols. She did both The Master AND The Muppets. It’s always felt like a matter of ‘when, not if’ in regards to her becoming an Oscar winner. But these past few years of Adams films have been, well, a bit rough.
My theory is that it started when Adams didn’t get an Oscar nomination for Best Actress for Arrival. Denis Villeneuve’s achingly humane sci-fi drama isn’t just one of her best films; it’s her greatest performance by a country mile. As Louise, a linguist tasked with finding a means of communication with an alien species, she is at her most tender and tenacious. As an actress, Adams’ greatest skill is her deceptive strength. She seems so sweet and approachable, very Girl Next Door, and that allows her the ability to sneak in moments of grit and devastation at unexpected times.

Adams’ Early Success and the Rise of Her Flop Era
Consider The Master, where she plays the wife of a cult leader, who mimics the expected part of the supportive spouse but slowly reveals her truth as the real power player behind the operation. With Arrival, she is wholly believable as the one human out of seven billion who is empathetic, intelligent, and sceptical enough to do what nobody else can. So, of course she didn’t get an Oscar nomination! Of course it was too good for the Academy in a year where they had to make room for yet another iffy late-era Meryl Streep performance.
After that, the films just got kind of bad. You can understand why Adams chose them: chances to work with acclaimed directors on buzzy material that felt like a shoo-in for a return to the podium. The results, however, were mostly DOA. Yes, she got nominated for Vice, for the thankless role of Lynne Cheney in a very bad and smug biopic, but it felt more like a courtesy nod than a celebratory one.
- Dear Evan Hansen was a mess.
- The Woman in the Window, endlessly delayed and shunted onto streaming, could have been camp fun but took itself far too seriously.
- Hillbilly Elegy was an unmitigated disaster for both culture and democracy, and also contained what is easily Adams’ worst performance.
These films were all, at one point in their pre-release hype, touted as Oscar nominees in waiting. Their failure to land a single nomination just made the notion of Adams being in her flop era that much stronger. It added a sheen of desperation to the mix, which obviously wasn’t fair but it was present nonetheless.

Adams’ Struggle to Find Her Footing in Recent Films
Failed Oscar bait does that to its participants. It didn’t help that none of these films gave Adams much to do. They were far more trope-laden than the works where she truly shines and she could only do so much with rotten material. The more it felt like Adams was trying to conform to the stifling mould of Academy-approved concepts, the more uninteresting the work became.
This is partly what makes Nightbitch, her latest release and a film I enjoyed, a frustrating experience. In an adaptation of Rachel Yoder’s novel, Adams plays the nameless Mother, a stay-at-home parent who is finding the repetition of her daily routine suffocating. As the film progresses, we see her gradually losing her grip on reality, becoming increasingly unhinged as she struggles to cope with the isolation and pressure of her role.
Despite its intriguing premise, Nightbitch ultimately falls short of its full potential. Adams’ performance, while nuanced and compelling, is hindered by a script that struggles to find a balance between drama and satire. The result is a film that feels disjointed and inconsistent, unable to fully commit to its central theme.

What Went Wrong with Amy Adams’ Recent Films?
So, what went wrong with Adams’ recent films? Was it a combination of factors, or a single event that set her career back on track? One thing is certain: Adams’ flop era has been a long and arduous one, with each new film failing to live up to the promise of its predecessor.
Let’s take a closer look at some of the key factors that may have contributed to Adams’ recent struggles. From the failure of Oscar bait to the stifling nature of trope-laden scripts, we’ll examine the ways in which Adams’ career has been impacted by the changing landscape of Hollywood.
The Failure of Oscar Bait
One of the biggest factors in Adams’ recent struggles is the failure of Oscar bait. With each new film, Adams has been presented with opportunities to showcase her range and versatility, only to see them fall flat. From Vice to Hillbilly Elegy, Adams has been typecast in roles that are more interested in winning awards than telling compelling stories.
This trend is not unique to Adams, of course. Many actors have struggled with the expectation of Oscar bait, only to see their careers suffer as a result. But Adams is no ordinary actress. With a track record of critically acclaimed performances, she should be able to transcend the limitations of Oscar bait and find success in a variety of roles.
The Stifling Nature of Trope-Laden Scripts
Another factor that may have contributed to Adams’ recent struggles is the stifling nature of trope-laden scripts. From the overly familiar characters of Dear Evan Hansen to the saccharine sentimentality of The Woman in the Window, Adams has been forced to navigate a world of clichés and stereotypes.
These scripts may be easy to market and sell, but they are a far cry from the complex, nuanced storytelling that Adams is known for. By relying on tired tropes and familiar characters, these films fail to challenge Adams as an actress, robbing her of the opportunity to showcase her range and versatility.
The Future of Amy Adams’ Career
So, what does the future hold for Amy Adams? Will she be able to bounce back from her recent struggles and reclaim her status as one of Hollywood’s leading ladies? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: Adams has the talent and dedication to succeed in this industry.
With a career spanning over two decades, Adams has proven herself to be a versatile and accomplished actress, capable of tackling a wide range of roles and genres. She has worked with some of the biggest names in the industry, from Spielberg to Villeneuve, and has been nominated for numerous awards, including six Oscars.
Despite her recent struggles, Adams remains one of the most beloved and respected actresses in Hollywood. Her dedication to her craft is unwavering, and her passion for storytelling is evident in every role she takes on. Whether she is playing a complex, nuanced character or a more lighthearted, comedic role, Adams brings a level of depth and authenticity to her performances that is hard to find in other actresses.
As we look to the future, it’s clear that Adams will continue to be a major force in Hollywood. With her talent, dedication, and passion for storytelling, she is poised to take on even greater challenges and achieve even greater success. Whether she will be able to reclaim her status as one of Hollywood’s leading ladies remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Amy Adams is a talented and accomplished actress who will continue to be a major player in this industry for years to come.
Conclusion
As we reflect on the career of Amy Adams, it’s clear that she has had her fair share of struggles. From the failure of Oscar bait to the stifling nature of trope-laden scripts, Adams has faced numerous challenges in her recent films. But despite these setbacks, Adams remains one of the most beloved and respected actresses in Hollywood.
With a career spanning over two decades, Adams has proven herself to be a versatile and accomplished actress, capable of tackling a wide range of roles and genres. She has worked with some of the biggest names in the industry, from Spielberg to Villeneuve, and has been nominated for numerous awards, including six Oscars.
As we look to the future, it’s clear that Adams will continue to be a major force in Hollywood. With her talent, dedication, and passion for storytelling, she is poised to take on even greater challenges and achieve even greater success. Whether she will be able to reclaim her status as one of Hollywood’s leading ladies remains to be seen, but one thing is certain: Amy Adams is a talented and accomplished actress who will continue to be a major player in this industry for years to come.